
An article published in The Weekend Australian on 28 March has highlighted a decrease in recent years in the amount of babies being home delivered. As homebirth babies have a two to three-fold risk if death, the issue is controversial and many people shy away from the topic. Recent mother, Natalie Hemingway gave birth to her 10 month old son at home. For her, it seemed the obvious choice.
“That’s what I saw when I was growing up, so birthing at home was normal to me,” says Hemingway, 27, who lives on Sydney’s lower north shore.
Homebirth in developed countries was the norm up until the past 50 years or so. In Australia today, homebirth can seem a radical choice, and the women who chose it anything from brave and alternative to misguided andloopy.
The recent federal government review of maternity services has done little to help bring the practice into the mainstream. It has inflamed an already heated debate over homebirths by stating it does not support Medicare funding of independent midwives attending homebirths. Described in the review as a controversial and sensitive issue that polarises the professions, it seems that homebirths are just too hot for Australia to handle, at least for now.
It seems both advocates and opponents of homebirth now have evidence to support their claims. A study of 5000 women planning homebirth in the US in 2000 provides gives the best available evidence surrounding the homeborth dilemma.
The results, published in the BMJ in 2005, showed that the rate of babies dying during labour or within 28 days of birth (intra-partum and neonatal mortality rate) was 1.7 deaths for every 1000 uncomplicated intended homebirths. The study (2005;330:1416-1419) said this was similar to risks in other studies of uncomplicated home and hospital births in North America.
The highly regarded Cochrane database, which assesses the highest quality evidence available, concludes that “there is no strong evidence to favour either home or hospital birth for selected, low-risk pregnant women”. Australian research, however, is scant and debates rage over what little research there is. In Holland, homebirth is an accepted government policy and the midwives who conduct homebirths are considered part of the medical profession. Maybe Australians greater conservative influences then that of our European counterparts. Either way, it seems homebirth, like many controversial issues, will always gather differenences in opinion.
According to Natalie Hemingway, “The biggest thing was being able to choose. Homebirth is just another choice that should be available to all women is that’s what they want.”